Nonfiction and narrative text
In chapter one, I was most intrigued
with the discussion about the use of narrative and nonfiction texts in the
classroom. In addition, the impact and changes predicted with the amount of
information our students will be expected to process and organize in their
lifetime. By the year 2020, it is predicted that the amount of information will
double every seventy-three days (Grolier, 1995). Therefore, it is our job to
make sure students are prepared to take on this surge of information and know
what to do with it in the context of reading and writing. Many instructional materials found in
elementary classrooms are narrative (i.e., fictional) texts. The authors define
narrative text as text that
tell stories and are organized sequentially, with a beginning, middle, and an
end. The basic plan or story grammar, of
narrative texts consists of such elements as characters, setting, plot and
theme. The purpose of fiction is to be engaging and entertaining and involve
the readers or listeners in stories about life, although the purpose of fiction
can be to inform or persuade (Fountas&Pinnell, 2001). Nonfiction
is defined as a carefully crafted genre, provides ideas, facts and principals
organized around main ideas, using both verbal and visual texts. To date,
trends in classroom across the country use less expository text and students
are far less familiar with expository writing and as a result have not been as
successful reading and writing in this genre.
This brings me to our discussion about
Rachel and Jeremy because; they too, struggled with using nonfiction text and
navigating assignment expectations. They were told to focus on key words, look
for important information, highlight as well as pick two ideas to discuss but
really did not know how to do this even when scaffolding appeared to be
happening during a lesson. This book enforces our discussion about the
importance of teaching text features and teaching students from a particular
Discourse to better understand how to read and write in a specific genre. (i.e.
“What does a historian look like? What does a historian want to know?”) In this
chapter, the authors created several graphs that outlined exactly what features
to look for in expository text from organizational features to graphic/visual
features. By outlining and organizing the content of nonfiction text, the
authors believed this would better assist teachers in supporting students in
learning expository text features. You could create this outline as an anchor
chart, with your students, as you learn specific features.
After class last week, I reevaluated how
I would begin my interest reading groups. I know that my students have not
experienced difficulties overall in filtering information, but I know I can do
a lot better at teaching them about text structures, what nonfiction is and how
we access information while reading and translate that into their writing. I
want to pick one topic and work on researching this as an entire class so we
can operate from a Discourse of historian, oceanographer, scientist, etc. I
want to model how to read from the lens of that Discourse and then break up
into smaller groups to work on a particular subject. My goal is that each
student will gain a deeper understanding through guided collaboration. We can
discuss our findings and difficulties as a group. I feel doing research, as an
entire class the first time, can ensure students are the historians or
scientist they need to be in order to truly understand the text and carry over
the lessons and skillset into the next lesson or subject matter. Thoughts?
I like how you tied in Rachel and Jeremy into your discussion. It brought me to my book which is about EL learners and academic literacy. One of the important part of the books is something Pauline Gibbons calls the Seven Intellectual Practices. One of those involves engaging the students in ways that the experts in the field think and reason. Students take on the roles and become that expert. It's like you are talking about....how Rachel and Jeremy needed to really see their reading texts as a historian would.
ReplyDeleteAlso seeing the information in different ways is an excellent way to really get our learners to engage and deepen their knowledge. Excellent book. I am intrigued!
Isnt' it so interesting how all of our readings and studies in this course are connected... because Penny talked to us last Thursday about how we should teach from the discipline's Discourse. This appears to be just like your reading... exciting!
ReplyDeleteA few years ago I was on the selection committee for our school's new reading curriculum. One of the key traits we were looking for in selecting a new program was more nonfiction, and expository selections. Unfortunately, there weren't many options. Luckily we found one that did include an expository text every third week. We've been using it two years now, so it's still early to judge how well it is working for our students just yet, but I have high hopes.
ReplyDeleteFrom what I have read, this book sounds great! I really like how you are able to tie our discussions into what you are writing. I think that it's important to teach from the discipline's discourse, because we help our students to take on new roles. I think it's important to teach text structures as you have mentioned, because nonfiction texts are sometimes inaccessible to the students and their needs. I really like what you have posted and again, look forward to reading more!
ReplyDeleteBravo! I would love to see how your new approach works out. The idea of identity and finding out what "these kinds" of people care and think about and what questions they ask can frame their initial reading.
ReplyDelete